Land Reform in Zimbabwe: a Balance of Political Expediency and Economic Inevitability?
The article considers the political aspect of land reform in the Republic of Zimbabwe. The problem of land reform has been one of the crucial ones in the history of this African country, which celebrated 40 years of independence on April 18, 2020. In recent decades, it has been constantly in the spotlight of political and electoral processes. The land issue was one of the key points of the political program from the very beginning of Robert Mugabe’s reign in 1980. The political aspect of land reform began to manifest itself clearly with the growth of the opposition movement in the late 1990s.
In 2000–2002 the country implemented the Fast Track Land Reform Program (FTLRP), the essence of which was the compulsory acquisition of land from white owners without compensation. The expropriation of white farmers’ lands in the 2000s led to a serious reconfiguration of land ownership, which helped to maintain in power the ruling party, the African National Union of Zimbabwe – Patriotic Front (ZANU – PF). The government was carrying out its land reform in the context of a sharp confrontation with the opposition, especially with the Party for the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), led by trade union leader Morgan Tsvangirai. The land issue was on the agenda of all the election campaigns (including the elections in July 2018); this fact denotes its politicization, hence the timeliness of this article. The economic and political crisis in Zimbabwe in the 2000–2010s was the most noticeable phenomenon in the South African region. The analysis of foreign and domestic sources allows us to conclude that the accelerated land reform served as one of its main triggers.
The practical steps of the new Zimbabwean president, Mr. Emmerson Mnangagwa, indicate that he is aware of the importance of resolving land reform-related issues for further economic recovery. At the beginning of March 2020, the government adopted new regulations defining the conditions for compensation to farmers. On April 18, 2020, speaking on the occasion of the 40th anniversary of the independence of Zimbabwe, Mr. E. Mnangagwa stated that the land reform program remains the cornerstone of the country’s independence and sovereignty.
land issue, land reform, ZANU – PF, land redistribution, opposition, crisis, sanctions, droughts, Mr. E. Mnangagwa, compensation
1. Abramova I.O., Fituni L.L. Tendencii ekonomicheskogo razvitiya i inflyacionnye processy v stranah Afriki yuzhnee Sahary (Economic development trends and inflationary processes in Sub-Saharan Africa). Problemy sovremennoj ekonomiki. 2016. № 4 (60). pp. 159–165. ISSN 1818-3395.
2. Abramova I.O., Fituni L.L., Sapuncov A.L. «Voznikayushchie» i «nesostoyavshiesya» gosudarstva v mirovoj ekonomike i politike (“Emerging” and “failed” states in global economy and politics). Moscow, Institute for African Studies RAS. 2007. 197 с. ISBN 978-5-91298-020-6.
3. Bond P. Zimbabve: politika v stile Mugabe (Zimbabwe: Politics, Mugabe Style). http://rabkor.ru/ columns/analysis/2019/03/19/mugabe-style (accessed 20.04.2020)
4. Chida P. Covid-19: Chamisa chides government. https://www.thestandard.co.zw/2020/04/19/covid-19-chamisa-chides-government (accessed 19.04.2020)
5. Chilunjika A., Uwizeyimana D.E. Shifts in the Zimbabwean Land Reform Discourse from 1980 to the present. African Journal of Public Affairs. 2015. vol. 8, issue 3, pp. 131–144. https://pdfs. semanticscholar.org/7771/61cfcd6e1bff87f82bf0ff8dd8ecd0670bbd.pdf (accessed 18.04.2020)
6. Cole B. Zimbabwe’s compensation promise to white farmers causes fury. https://www.iol.co. za/sunday-tribune/news/zimbabwes-compensation-promise-to-white-farmers-causes-fury-21114654 (accessed 18.04.2020)
7. Constitution of Zimbabwe (Final Draft: January 2013). Part 4, Article 124 (1 (b)) (accessed 20.04.2020)
8. Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996. Chapter 2: Bill of Rights. Section 25 (1–9). http://www.justice.gov.za/legislation/constitution/SAConstitution-web-eng.pdf (accessed 19.04.2020)
9. Demkina L.A. Socialno-ekonomicheskie predposylki krizisa v Zimbabve v konce 90-h gg. XX veka (Socio-economic preconditions of the crisis in Zimbabwe in late 90s.) Yug Afriki. Nasledie proshlogo i nastoyashchee. Moscow, Institute for African Studies RAS. 2006. 236 p. ISBN 5-201-04838-2.
10. De Villiers, B. Land reform: Issues and Challenges – A Comparative Review of Experiences in Zimbabwe, Namibia, South Africa and Australia. Johannesburg: Konrad Adenauer Foundation. 2003. 172 p. ISBN 9780620303699.
11. Freeth B. Zimbabwe government’s land for compensation offer is misleading. https://www.thezimbabwean.co/2020/03/zimbabwe-governments-land-for-compensation-offer-is-misleading (accessed 18.04.2020)
12. Global Political Agreement. Article V Land Question (5 (3)). https://www.pindula.co.zw/ Global_Political_Agreement (accessed 20.04.2020)
13. Global Political Agreement. Article V Land Question (5 (4)). https://www.pindula.co.zw/ Global_Political_Agreement (accessed 20.04.2020)
14. Hamatshin A.D. Zemelnye otnosheniya I razvitie selskohozajstvennogo proizvodstva na Yuge Afriki. (Land relations and agricultural development in Southern Africa). Ph. Diss. (Econ.). Moscow. 2014.
15. Helliker K. Review of Ian Scoones et al. Zimbabwe’s Land Reform: Myths and Realities. Journal of Contemporary African Studies. 2011, vol. 29, issue 3, pp. 349–359. http://www.reuters.com/ newsArticle.jhtml?type=topNews&storyID=8011555 (accessed 18.04.2020)
16. Hudleston S. Face of Courage. A Biography of Morgan Tsvangirai. Cape Town. Double Storey. 2005. 159 p. ISBN 1 77013 005 5.
17. Land Reform in the Twenty Years After Independence. http://www.hrw.org/reports/2002/ zimbabwe/ZimLand0302-02.htm (accessed 10.04.2020)
18. Laurie C. The Land Reform Deception: Political Opportunism in Zimbabwe’s Land Seizure Era. Oxford University Press, 2016. 424 p. ISBN 978-0190680527.
19. Lodge T. Thinking about SA land reform. https://www.politicsweb.co.za/opinion/thinking-about-sa-land-reform (accessed 17.04.2020)
20. Madhuku L. Law, Politics and the Land Reform Process in Zimbabwe. Post-Independence Land Reform in Zimbabwe: Controversies and Impact on the Economy. Harare: Friedrich Ebert Stiftung and Institute of Development Studies. 2004, pp. 124–146. ISBN: 0-7974-2786-4.
21. Maphenduka J. Govt takes plunge to compensate white farmers. https://www.thestandard. co.zw/2019/12/22/govt-takes-plunge-compensate-white-farmers) (accessed 18.04.2020)
22. Marawanyika G., Sguazzin A. Zimbabwe gives land back to white farmers after wrecking economy. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-13/zimbabwe-offers-land-to-recom-pense-dispossessed-white-farmers (accessed 16.04.2020)
23. Mkodzongi G., Lawrence P. The fast-track land reform and agrarian change in Zimbabwe. Review of African Political Economy. 2019, vol. 46, issue 159, pp. 1–13. https://www.tandf-online.com/doi/full/10.1080/03056244.2019.1622210 (accessed 20.04.2020)
24. Morgan Tsvangirai (with T. William Barongo). Morgan Tsvangirai: At the Deep End, Johannesburg: Penguin Books. 2011. 564 p. ISBN 978-0-14302-682-2.
25. New Zimbabwe Pledge for a Sustainable and Modernisation Agenda for Real Trasformation. MDC Alliance Smart Pledge 2018. Chapter 3. Part II (3.8). https://t792ae.c2.acecdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/MDC-ALLIANCE-SMART-MANIFESTO.pdf (accessed 18.04.2020)
26. Onslow S., Plaut M. Robert Mugabe (Ohio Short Histories of Africa). Ohio University Press, 2018. 208 p. ISBN 978-0821423240.
27. Pilossof R. The Land Question (Un) Resolved: An Essay Review. Historia. 2008, vol. 53, issue 2, pp. 270–279. http://www.scielo.org.za/pdf/hist/v53n2/12.pdf (accessed 10.04.2020)
28. President Mnangagwa’s inauguration speech in full. https://www.chronicle.co.zw/president-mnangagwas-inauguration-speech-in-full-2 (accessed 18.04.2020)
29. Prokopenko L.Ya. Novye politicheskie elity v gosudarstvah Yuga Afriki (New political elites in Southern Africa countries). Moscow, Institute for African Studies RAS. 2011. 252 p. ISBN 978-5-91298-092-3.
30. Prokopenko L.Ya. Zhenshchiny i vlast (na primere stran Yuga Afriki) (Women and Power (Southern Africa countries)). Moscow, Institute for African Studies RAS. 2018. 206 p. ISBN 978-5-91298-217-0.
31. Salahetdinov E.R. Vliyanie vneshnih faktorov na krizis v Zimbabve v nachale XX veka. (Influence of external factors on the crisis in Zimbabwe in early XX cent). Ph. Diss. (Hist.). Moscow. 2015.
32. Shubin V.G. Zimbabve, krizis preodolen? (Zimbabwe, the crisis is over?) Aziya i Afrika Segodnya. 2012, № 5, pp. 23–25. ISSN 0321-5075.
33. Shubin V.G. Zimbabve, krizis preodolen? (Zimbabwe, the crisis is over?) http://naukarus. com/zimbabve-krizis-preodolen (accessed 20.04.2020)
34. Shubin V.G. Sudby Zimbabve (Fates of Zimbabwe). Moscow, Institute for African Studies RAS. 2015. 158 p. ISBN 978-5-91298-160-9.
35. Shubin G.V. Krizis v Zimbabve (1997–2007) (Crisis in Zimbabwe (1997–2007)). Problems of development, South Africa and Zimbabwe. Collected essays). Moscow, Memories. 2007. 75 p. ISBN 9-785903116355.
36. Shumba G. A critical reflection on the 2002 presidential election in Zimbabwe. African Human Rights Law Journal. 2002, vol. 2, issue 1, pp. 327–346. ISSN 1996-2096. https://www.ahrlj. up.ac.za/images/ahrlj/2002/ahrlj_vol2_no2_2002_gabriel_shumba.pdf (accessed 18.04.2020)
37. Southall R. Too Soon to Tell? Land Reform in Zimbabwe. Africa Spectrum. Hamburg: GIGA German Institute of Global and Area Studies. 2011, vol. 46, issue 3, pp. 83–97. ISSN 0002-0397.
38. Sguazzin A. Zimbabwe’s Currency Plans Upended as It Fights on Two Fronts. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-13/zimbabwe-offers-land-to-recompense-dis-possessed-white-farmers (accessed 18.04.2020)
39. Timberg C. U.N. to Resume Food Aid to Zimbabwe. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/06/01/AR2005060100908.html (accessed 18.04.2020)
40. Towindo L. Govt moves to clean anomalies on farms. https://www.sundaymail.co.zw/some-farmers-to-get-land-back-as-govt-moves-to-clean-anomalies-on-farms (accessed 17.04.2020)
41. Tsvangirai on land reform. https://www.farmersweekly.co.za/archive/tsvangirai-on-land-reform (accessed 18.04.2020)
42. Winter J. Zimbabwe land reform ‘not a failure’. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-11764004 (accessed 19.04.2020)
43. ZANU PF. The People’s Manifesto 2018. https://www.zanupf.org.zw/wp-content/uploads/ ZANU_PF_2018_MANIFESTO_ENGLISH.pdf (accessed 18.04.2020)
44. ZIM@40, PRESIDENT MNANGAGWA’S UHURU SPEECH: LET’S CHERISH LEGACY OF PEACE. https://www.zanupf.org.zw/zim40-president-mnangagwas-uhuru-speech-lets-cherish-legacy-of-peace (accessed 19.04.2020)
45. Zimbabwe’s farms. Whose land? https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2009/03/05/ whose-land (accessed 18.04.20)
46. Zimbabwe’s white farmers: Who will pay compensation? https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-48264941 (accessed 21.04.2020)