The Nile Bargain – JOURNAL OF THE INSTITUTE FOR AFRICAN STUDIES

Author:

Stanislav Mezentsev, Pavel Tsarev

Abstract:

The article analyses the serious regional crisis connected with the end of the construction of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam on the Blue Nile. This project, due to be launched in July 2020, sparks tensions between Ethiopia and Egypt. Both sides are doing their utmost to get international support for their respective positions. Cairo urges not to fill the Dam before settling all the disputed issues. Addis Ababa wants to do it as quickly as possible to make the Dam operational. However, the window of diplomatic opportunities for a consensus is just about to close. Egypt threatens to use military force, and Ethiopia is ready to mobilize one million people to protect the Dam. Who is in the right? Which country is stronger? Could Egypt and Ethiopia really go to war over water? The authors try to answer these questions, analyzing the legislative base of the Nile case, the military potential of both countries and the attitude of the main world actors towards this problem.

Comparing available open source data, authors conclude that a war between the two states is almost impossible. What is happening now around the Dam looks more like a big bargain, and its subject is the Egypt’s future chances to remain one of the main regional and continental political and economic players. There are only two ways to delay filling the dam: monetary compensation from Egypt or future destabilization of internal situation in Ethiopia.

Keywords:

Egypt, Ethiopia, Nile, Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD)

DOI:

10.31132/2412-5717-2020-52-3-112-132

References:

1. Abadir M. Ibrahim. The Nile Basin Cooperative Framework Agreement: The Beginning of the End of Egyptian Hydro-Political Hegemony. https://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/cgi/ viewcontent.cgi?article=1395&context=jesl (accessed 28.06.2020)
2. Aboudouh A. Blood on the Nile is what’s coming if Egypt and Ethiopia continue their war of words over water. https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/egypt-nile-war-water-ethiopia-clash-dam-trump-a9390271.html (accessed 28.06.2020)
3. Africa Water Atlas. Nairobi. 2010. 326 p. ISBN: 978-92-807-3110-1.
4. Agreement between The Republic of The Sudan and The United Arab Republic for the full utilization of the Nile waters. The United Nations. https://treaties.un.org/doc/Publication/UNTS/ Volume%20453/volume-453-I-6519-English.pdf (accessed 28.06.2020)
5. Agreement on Declaration of Principles between Egypt, Ethiopia and Sudan on the GERDP. https://www.sis.gov.eg/Story/121609/Agreement-on-Declaration-of-Principles-between-Egypt%2C-Ethiopia-and–Sudan-on-the-GERDP?lang=en-us (accessed 28.06.2020)
6. Almohsen Rehab Abd. Ethiopian dam plans spark regional tensions. http://www.scidev.net/ global/water/feature/ethiopian-dam-plans-spark-regional-tensions.html (accessed 30.06.2020)

7. Arab FMs support Egypt’s position on Ethiopian Nile dam issue. Xinhua. http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2020-06/24/c_139162120.htm (accessed 29.06.2020)
8. Background Briefing With Senior State Department Official. U.S. Department of State. https://www.state.gov/senior-state-department-official-2/ (accessed 29.06.2020)
9. Breaking News: Egypt based hackers attempted cyber attacks on Ethiopian gov’t sites. https://africans.press/2020/06/24/breaking-news-egypt-based-hackers-attempted-cyber-attacks-on-ethiopian-govt-sites/ (accessed 30.06.2020)
10. Brifing oficialnogo predstavitelja MID Rossii M.V.Zaharovoj, Moskva, 4 ijunja 2020 goda. (Briefing of the official spokesperson of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation M.V Zakharova, July 4th, 2020. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation) MID RF. https://www.mid.ru/web/guest/ukraine/-/asset_publisher/HfLxJk5I2xvu/content/id/4148999#19 (accessed 29.06.2020)
11. Calmer Waters: Nile Basin Countries Co-Operate in Water-Sharing Treaty. https://www.questia. com/magazine/1P3-758736431/calmer-waters-nile-basin-countries-co-operate-in (accessed 28.06.2020)
12. China urges Ethiopia to talk anew to Egypt about filling dam on Nile. https://www.businesslive. co.za/bd/world/africa/2020-05-21-china-urges-ethiopia-to-talk-anew-to-egypt-about-filling-dam-on-nile/ (accessed 29.06.2020)
13. Chinese firms brought in to «pick up pace» on Ethiopia’s Nile dam. https://www.global constructionreview.com/news/chinese-firms-brought-pick-pace-ethiopias-nile-dam/ (accessed 29.06.2020)
14. Communiqué of the Extraordinary African Union (AU) Bureau of the Assembly of Heads of State and Government video-teleconference Meeting on the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD). The African Union. https://au.int/en/pressreleases/20200626/hosg-communique-meetinng-grand-ethiopian-renaissance-dam-gerd (accessed 30.06.2020)
15. Cooperative Framework Agreement. https://nilebasin.org/nbi/cooperative-framework-agreement (accessed 28.06.2020)
16. Daily Press Briefing – April 29, 2014. U.S. Department of State. http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ prs/dpb/2014/04/225362.htm (accessed 29.06.2020)
17. Daily Press Briefing – March 24, 2015. U.S. Department of State. http://www.state.gov/ r/pa/prs/dpb/2015/03/239735.htm (accessed 29.06.2020)
18. Davison W. Ethiopia Says It Has Evidence That Egypt Supported Rebels. Bloomberg. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2010-11-25/ethiopia-says-it-has-evidence-that-egypt-supported-rebels (accessed 28.06.2020)
19. Egipet i Sudan osudili soglashenie ob ispol’zovanii vod Nila. (Egypt and Sudan condemned the agreement on the use of the Nile water) RIA Novosti. http://eco.rian.ru/business/20100521/ 236868694.html (accessed 28.06.2020)
20. Egipet, Sudan i Jefiopija dogovorilis’ naschet strojashhejsja jefiopskoj GЕS (Egypt, Sudan and Ethiopia have reached an agreement regarding the Ethiopian hydroelectric power plant under construction). RIA Novosti. http://ria.ru/world/20150323/1054025156.html (accessed 28.06.2020)
21. Egipet, Sudan i Jefiopija podpishut soglashenie po plotine v konce fevralja (Egypt, Sudan and Ethiopia to sign an agreement on the dam at the end of the February). RIA Novosti. https://ria.ru/20200201/1564133409.html (accessed 29.06.2020)
22. Egipetskij funt: istorija interesnoj valjuty (The Egyptian pound: a history of an interesting currency). https://ru.egyptian.today/ocherk/3186-40-13-17.html (accessed 28.06.2020)
23. Egypt and the Nile Basin: Benefits of Cooperation. https://nilebasin.org/images/country_ profile/Egypt.pdf (accessed 28.06.2020)
24. Egypt. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. http://www.fao.org/nr/water/ aquastat/data/query/results.html (accessed 28.06.2020)
25. Egypt rejects Ethiopia’s statement on Arab League resolution over Nile dam. Xinhua. http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2020-03/08/c_138853897.htm (accessed 29.06.2020)
26. Egypt. The United Nations. http://data.un.org/en/iso/eg.html (accessed 28.06.2020)
27. Egypt’s el-Sisi orders army to be ready for missions abroad. https://www.aljazeera. com/news/2020/06/egypt-el-sisi-orders-army-ready-missions-200620153149555.html (accessed 29.06.2020)
28. Egypt’s Limited Military Options to Stop an Ethiopian Dam Project. https://worldview.stratfor. com/article/egypts-limited-military-options-stop-ethiopian-dam-project (accessed 28.06.2020)
29. Egypt’s Sisi denies supporting opposition in Ethiopia. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-ethiopia-unrest-egypt-idUSKCN12D2KN (accessed 28.06.2020)
30. Ethiopia contracts Chinese companies to complete Nile dam construction. https://www.africa news.com/2019/02/19/ethiopia-contracts-chinese-companies-to-complete-nile-dam-construction/ (accessed 29.06.2020)
31. Ethiopia. The United Nations. http://data.un.org/en/iso/et.html (accessed 28.06.2020)
32. Ethiopian dam plans spark regional tensions. http://www.scidev.net/global/water/feature/ ethiopian-dam-plans-spark-regional-tensions.html (accessed 28.06.2020)
33. Farhadi F. Egypt and Ethiopia are in battle array. https://www.tehrantimes.com/news/446210/ Egypt-and-Ethiopia-are-in-battle-array (accessed 28.06.2020)
34. Four African countries sign new Nile treaty. http://www.alarabiya.net/ articles/2010/05/14/ 108577.html (accessed 28.06.2020)
35. Friction with Cairo over the Israel air defense system for Ethiopia’s Great Nile dam. https://www.debka.com/friction-with-cairo-over-the-israel-air-defense-system-for-ethiopias-great-nile-dam/ (accessed 30.06.2020)
36. Gashev B.N., Zudina L.P. Vodoobespechenie v arabskih stranah Severnoj Afriki. (Water supply in the Arab countries of North Africa) Blizhniy Vostok i sovremennost. №38. Moscow, 2009, p. 5–27. ISBN 978-5-89282-376-0.
37. Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam Project, Benishangul-Gumuz, Ethiopia. http://www.water-technology.net/projects/grand-ethiopian-renaissance-dam-africa (accessed 28.06.2020)
38. Guterres encourages Member States to reach agreement over Ethiopian Nile dam project. UN News. https://news.un.org/en/story/2020/05/1064452 (accessed 29.06.2020)
39. INSA Foils Cyber Attacks from Egypt. https://ecadforum.com/2020/06/24/insa-foils-cyber-attacks-from-egypt/ (accessed 30.06.2020)
40. Iraqi president receives letter from Egyptian president over Nile water rights. http://www.china.org.cn/world/Off_the_Wire/2020-03/09/content_75789536.htm (accessed 29.06.2020)
41. Is an Egypt-Ethiopia war an option? A comparison between the Egyptian and Ethiopian armies. https://www.egyptindependent.com/is-an-egypt-ethiopia-war-an-option-a-comparison-between-the-egyptian-and-ethiopian-armies/ (accessed 28.06.2020)
42. Israel denies providing defence systems for Ethiopian dam. https://www.middle eastmonitor.com/20190708-israel-denies-providing-defence-systems-for-ethiopian-dam/ (accessed 30.06.2020)
43. Jefiopija i Egipet obmenjalis’ rezkimi zajavlenijami po plotine na Nile (Ethiopia and Egypt exchanged harsh statements on the Nile dam). RIA Novosti. https://ria.ru/20191023/1560091586.html (accessed 29.06.2020)
44. Jefiopija reshila zapolnit’ plotinu na Golubom Nile bez «blagoslovenija» Egipta (Ethiopia decided to fill the Blue Nile dam without Egypt’s “blessing”). Vzgliad. https://vz.ru/news/2020/6/ 20/1046038.html (accessed 29.06.2020)
45. Krutikov E. Jefiopy vozvodjat objekt, sposobnyj unichtozhit’ Egipet (The Ethiopians are constructing an object capable of destroying Egypt). Vzgliad. https://vz.ru/world/2020/6/15/1045072.html (accessed 29.06.2020)
46. Morsi: If our share of Nile water decreases, our blood will be the alternative. https://wwww.daily newssegypt.com/2013/06/11/morsi-if-our-share-of-nile-water-decreases-our-blood-will-be-the-alternative/ (accessed 28.06.2020)
47. Nazarova A. Damba na Nile grozit novym konfliktom v Afrike (The Nile dam threatens with a new conflict in Africa). Vzgliad. https://vz.ru/news/2020/6/15/1044969.html (accessed 29.06.2020)
1. telefonnom razgovore Ministra inostrannyh del Rossijskoj Federacii S.V.Lavrova s Ministrom inostrannyh del Arabskoj Respubliki Egipet S.Shukri (On the telephone conversation of the Foreign Minister of the Russian Federation S.V.Lavrov with the Foreign Minister of the Arab Republic of Egypt S. Shukri). MID RF. https://www.mid.ru/web/guest/telefonnye-razgovory-ministra/-/asset_publisher/KLX3tiYzsCLY/content/id/4145714 (accessed 29.06.2020)
2. telefonnom razgovore Ministra inostrannyh del Rossijskoj Federacii S.V.Lavrova s Ministrom inostrannyh del Arabskoj Respubliki Egipet Samehom Shukri (On the telephone conversation of the Foreign Minister of the Russian Federation S.V.Lavrov with the Foreign Minister of the Arab Republic of Egypt Sameh Shukri). MID RF. https://www.mid.ru/web/guest/telefonnye-razgovory-ministra/-/asset_publisher/KLX3tiYzsCLY/content/id/4170504 (accessed 29.06.2020)
3. telefonnom razgovore Ministra inostrannyh del Rossijskoj Federacii S.V.Lavrova s Prem’er-ministrom Federativnoj Demokraticheskoj Respubliki Jefiopii Abijem Ahmedom (On the telephone conversation of the Foreign Minister of the Russian Federation S.V.Lavrov with the Prime Minister of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia Abiy Ahmed). MID RF. https://www.mid.ru/ foreign_policy/news/-/asset_publisher/UdAzvXr89FbD/content/id/4177247 (accessed 29.06.2020)
4. vstreche zamestitelja Ministra inostrannyh del Rossii S.V.Vershinina s Poslom Egipta v Moskve I.Nasrom (On the meeting of the Deputy Foreign Minister S.V.Vershinin with the ambassador of Egypt to Russia I. Nasr). MID RF. https://www.mid.ru/web/guest/ukraine/-/asset_publisher/ HfLxJk5I2xvu/content/id/4172031 (accessed 29.06.2020)
48. Okoth-Owiro A. The Nile Treaty. State Succession and International Treaty Commitments: A Case Study of the Nile Water Treaties. Nairobi. 2004. 104 p. ISSN 1681-5890
49. OON sledit za sporom mezhdu Egiptom, Jefiopiej i Sudanom iz-za plotiny na Golubom Nile (The UN watches the dispute between Egypt, Ethiopia and Sudan caused by the Blue Nile dam). TASS. https://tass.ru/mezhdunarodnaya-panorama/8792323 (accessed 29.06.2020)
50. Picard F., Xenos A. Tension on the Nile: Could Egypt and Ethiopia really go to war over water? https://www.france24.com/en/africa/20200625-debate-tension-on-the-nile-could-egypt-and-ethiopia-really-go-to-war-over-water (accessed 28.06.2020)
51. Po iniciative egipetskoj storony sostojalsja telefonnyj razgovor Vladimira Putina s Prezidentom Arabskoj Respubliki Egipet Abdel’fattahom Sisi (A telephone conversation between Vladimir Putin and the President of the Arab Republic of Egypt Abdel Fattah Sisi was held at the initiative of the Egyptian side). Prezident Rossii. http://www.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/63485 (accessed 29.06.2020)
52. Press Release on The Extraordinary Meeting of the Bureau of the African Union Assembly on the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam. https://twitter.com/PMEthiopia/status/1276772158564380672/ photo/1 (accessed 30.06.2020)
53. Prezident Egipta priglasil Putina na nachalo stroitelstva AES v Ed-Dabaa. (The Egyptian President invited Putin for the groundbreaking ceremony of the El Dabaa nuclear power plant) RIA Novosti. https://ria.ru/20191023/1560099901.html?in=t (accessed 29.06.2020)
54. Rossija postavila Jefiopii ZRPK «Pancir’-S1», zajavili v «Rosoboronjeksporte» (Rosoboronexport: Russia supplied Ethiopia with Pantsir-S1). RIA Novosti. https://ria.ru/20191023/ 1560097846.html (accessed 29.06.2020)
55. Sostojalas’ prezentacija Rossijskoj promyshlennoj zony v Egipte (A presentation of the Russian industrial zone in Egypt was held). https://www.exportcenter.ru/press_center/news/sostoyalas-prezentatsiya-rossiyskoy-promyshlennoy-zony-v-egipte/ (accessed 29.06.2020)
56. South Sudan denies allowing Egypt military base near Ethiopia. https://www.middleeast monitor.com/20200605-south-sudan-denies-allowing-egypt-military-base-near-ethiopia/ (accessed 30.06.2020)
57. Tekle Tesfa-Alem. Ethiopians urge US to play major role to resolve Nile water controversy. http://www.sudantribune.com/spip.php?article35907 (accessed 29.06.2020)
58. The Military balance 2017. NY: The International Institute For Strategic Studies, 2017. 572 p. DOI: 10.1080/04597222.2017.1271205
59. UNSC urges consensus, warns against unilateral actions during meeting on GERD. http://english.ahram.org.eg/NewsContent/1/0/373239/Egypt/0/UPDATED-UNSC-urges-consensus,-warns-against-unilat.aspx (accessed 30.06.2020)
60. V Jefiopii chislo pogibshih v hode protestov iz-za smerti pevca dostiglo 239 (Death toll in Ethiopian protests caused by singer’s death reaches 239). RIA Novosti. https://ria.ru/20200708/ 1574043411.html (accessed 08.07.2020)
61. Volkov K. Spor Egipta i Jefiopii za vodu Nila ugrozhaet vsej Evrope (The dispute over the Nile’s water between Egypt and Ethiopia threatens the whole Europe). Rossiyskaya gazeta https://rg.ru/2020/06/16/spor-egipta-i-efiopii-za-vodu-nila-ugrozhaet-vsej-evrope.html (accessed 29.06.2020)
62. Walsh D., Sengupta S. For Thousands of Years, Egypt Controlled the Nile. A New Dam Threatens That. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/02/09/world/africa/nile-river-dam.html (accessed 28.06.2020)
63. Water Scarcity in Egypt: The Urgent Need for Regional Cooperation among the Nile Basin Countries. https://globalhealthnewswire.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Egypt%20Water%20Resources %20Paper_2014.pdf (accessed 28.06.2020)
64. Zenitnyj raketno-pushechnyj kompleks 96K6 «Pancir’-S1» (SA-22 GREYHOUND) (Antiaircraft missile and gun complex 96K6 “Pantsir-S1” (SA-22 GREYHOUND)). Novosti VPK. https://vpk. name/library/f/pancir.html (accessed 29.06.2020)

Full Article