Moulding South African Public Opinion on Economic Cooperation with Russia
A study of over 300 articles and opinion pieces in popular and academic publications in South Africa, issued in 2016–2021, shows that South African journalists and political scientists are sceptical of large state-sponsored economic projects involving Russian state companies.
Statements by the Russian partners that the current economic initiatives uphold the tradition of Soviet assistance to the anti-apartheid movement are interpreted by critics of the South African government as demagoguery and exploitation of history. Such authors assert that Russian-South African state cooperation in business led to “dodgy deals” which were concluded in the interests of South African high officials as well as entrepreneurs associated with them. South African journalists and political scientists focus on internal political and economic problems, presenting Russian initiatives as an aggravating factor.
Many leading members of the ANC and the EFF have spoken in favour of cooperation with Russian state companies. Such initiatives are also often supported by the Independent Media & News publications. Collaboration between Russian private companies and their local partners does not tend to raise objections from observers in that country. South Africans welcome joint ventures with Russian participation which not only create jobs and provide advanced training to their local personnel but also contribute to import substitution by establishing manufacturing facilities in South Africa.
The previous failures have not discredited trade and economic cooperation with Russia. South Africans do not seem to be opposed to Russian economic initiatives, apart from major state projects which are often scrutinised by the media. A considerable number of South Africans view Russia as an alternative to the Western influence and favour economic collaboration between our countries.
Russian-South African cooperation, South African media, Rosatom, Jacob Zuma, Julius Malema, public opinion, image of Russia in South Africa, Russian economic initiatives, Russian investments in South Africa
1. Abramova I.O. Fituni L.L. Adaptatsiya “afrikanskogo vektora” vneshneekonomicheskoy politiki RF k menyayushcheysya ekonomicheskoy konyunkture na kontinente (Adjusting the «African vector» of Russia’s foreign economic policy to the changes in the economic environment on the continent). Journal of the Institute for African Studies. 2017, vol. 38, № 1, pp. 24–36.
2. Allison S. Russia and South Africa, together for decades. https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/ article/2014-09-24-analysis-russia-and-south-africa-together-for-decades (accessed 12.05.2021)
3. Allison S. Russia in Africa: Soft power comes with hard edges. Mail & Guardian. 24.10.2019.
4. Allison S. Russia is the clumsy latecomer at Africa’s superpower party. Mail & Guardian. 12.06.2019.
5. Amusan L. Seeking relevance in the age of globalisation: Russia in Africa through South Africa. Journal of African Union Studies. 2018, vol. 7, № 1, p. 151–172.
6. Arkhangelskaya A. Dodd N. Guns and poseurs: Russia returns to Africa. Van der Merwe J., Taylor I., Arkhangelskaya A. (eds). Emerging Powers in Africa: A New Wave in the Relationship? Cham. Palgrave Macmillan. 2016. 289 p.
7. BRICS Joint Statistical Publication 2020; Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa. Moscow. Rosstat. 2020. 226 p.
8. Callaghan N. Kachur D. Swilling M. China and Russia in Africa: Development allies or geopolitical opportunists? https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2020-08-05-china-and-russia-in-africa-development-allies-or-geopolitical-opportunists (accessed 20.05.2021)
9. Department of Energy, Republic of South Africa. Integrated Resource Plan (IRP2019). Pretoria, 2019. 98 p.
10. Dludla S. Russian group eager to get rolling. The Star. 05.09.2019.
11. Du Preez M. Did Zuma cross Putin? https://www.news24.com/news24/Columnists/Maxdu Preez/did-zuma-cross-putin-20171024 (accessed 22.05.2021)
12. Economic Freedom Fighters, Twitter, 14 April 2021. https://twitter.com/EFFSouthAfrica/status/ 1382201839291150337 (accessed 05.06.2021)
13. Faull L. Exposed: Scary details of SA’s secret Russian nuke deal. Mail & Guardian. 13.02.2015.
14. Given Majola. KZN manufacturing sector generates 20% of province’s employment. Business Report. 13.10.2019.
15. Gopaldas R. Vaccine diplomacy becomes a new weapon in a new superpower game. Business Day. 12.01.2021.
16. Haffajee F. Malema goes nuclear on Eskom’s future. https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/ 2020-03-01-malena-goes-nuclear-on-eskoms-future (accessed 02.06.2021)
17. Kahn T. State looks to buy millions of Russian and Chinese vaccines. Business Day. 29.04.2021.
18. Khaas T. Time for Cyril to put SA first. City Press. 18.02.2018.
19. Kings S. State’s hopes for a nuclear future nuked. Mail & Guardian. 28.04.2017.
20. Leon T. Fools are Russian in. The Times (Johannesburg). 06.09.2017.
21. Malema says SA should collaborate with Russia, Cuba on vaccine. https://www.enca.com/ news/malema-says-sa-should-collaborate-russia-cuba-vaccine (accessed 10.06.2021)
22. Marrian N., Quintal G. Zuma link – PetroSA signs $400m deal with Russia’s Rosgeo. Business Day. 05.09.2017.
23. Maryam J. Banday U.J. Mittal A. Trade intensity and revealed comparative advantage: an analysis of Intra-BRICS trade. International Journal of Emerging Markets. 2018, vol. 13, № 5, pp. 1182–1195.
24. Mashele P. ANC is selling our country to China. Sowetan. 05.10.2015.
25. Masondo S. New energy deal with Moscow uncovered. Sunday Times. 31.05.2020.
26. Matisonn J. How Russia eased its way into SA nuclear. City Press. 02.02.2020.
27. Maughan K. Zuma stands by his Russian nuclear deal. Business Day. 22.03.2019.
28. Monaheng K. Make time to stay off the internet. Daily Sun. 21.11.2019.
29. Monyamane M.M. Adney M. Time to make South Africa’s relationship with China mutually beneficial. https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2020-04-20-time-to-make-south-africas-relation-ship-with-china-mutually-beneficial (accessed 02.06.2021)
30. Nare S. Too slow for my liking! – Malema calls for 24/7 Covid jabs. Daily Sun. 01.04.2021.
31. Ndletyana M. Which country will Mabuza serve? City Press. 14.04.2019.
32. Nuclear energy campaign. Earthlife Africa. https://earthlife.org.za/campaign-nuclear-energy (accessed 20.05.2021)
33. Obraztsova M.G. Sotrudnichestvo Rossiya–YuAR: ot upushchennykh vozmozhnostey – k potentsialu rosta (Russia-South Africa Cooperation: from Missed Opportunities to Growth Potential). Asia and Africa Today. 2019, № 4, pp. 64–69.
34. Olivier G. Unable to beat rivals in trade, Russia may try an agent provocateur role. Business Day. 22.03.2019.
35. Pressly D. ANC link to Russian mining venture emerges. The Star. 19.04.2010.
36. Qobo M. Dube M. South Africa’s foreign economic strategies in a changing global system. South African Journal of International Affairs. 2015, vol. 2, № 22, pp. 145–164.
37. Quintal G. Zuma fired me over nuclear deal – Nene. Business Day. 04.10.2018.
38. Ross A. China’s R370bn “gift” demands scrutiny. Mail & Guardian. 17.09.2018.
39. Russia’s latest great game in Africa: energy. https://www.miningweekly.com/article/russias-latest-great-game-in-africa-energy-2019-06-10 (accessed 22.05.2021)
40. Salakhetdinov E.R. Sidorov V.A. Rossiyskie proekty i energeticheskoe sotrudnichestvo v Yuzhnoy Afrike (Russian Projects and Energy Cooperation in South Africa). Studies on Russian Economic Development. 2018, vol. 166, № 11, pp. 142–151.
41. Schoeman A. DA vra vrae oor Russe se kontrak. Rapport. 17.09.2017.
42. Shubin V.G. Rossiya i Yuzhnaya Afrika: voobrazhenie i deystvitel’nost’ (Russia and South Africa: imagination and reality). Neprikosnovennyy zapas. 2020, № 132 (4), pp. 304–317.
43. Sidiropoulos E. Alden C. Inside the Russia-Africa Matryoshka: Summitry, Geopolitics and Resources. A Working Paper, October 2019. Pretoria. South African Institute of International Relations. 2019. 35 p.
44. Skubko Y.S. K itogam parlamentskikh vyborov v YuAR v 2019 godu (To the results of the RSA parliamentary elections of 2019). Vybory v stranakh Yuga Afriki. Sbornik statey (Elections in the South of Africa. A collection of articles). Moscow: Institute for African Studies, Russian Academy of Sciences, 2020. pp. 12–24.
45. The State Capacity Research Project. Betrayal of the Promise: How South Africa is Being Stolen. Stellenbosch, 2017. 63 p.
46. Wa Afrika M. Jika T. Zuma’s pals in R5bn gas deal. Sunday Times. 17.09.2017.
47. Williams F. Russe soek na aardgas aan Suid-Kaap se kus. Die Burger. 05.09.2017.
48. Williams M. Zuma’s Russian roulette. The Citizen. 14.02.2018.